8.5–10 Outstanding
7.0–8.4 Excellent
5.5–6.9 Good
4.0–5.4 Mixed
0–3.9 Poor
All Providers — Click to Read Full Analysis
Fuelmate
Fuel card broker · fuelmate.co.uk
8.7
/10
4.9★ Trustpilot
Shell Reseller 2025
No hidden fees
Highest-rated provider in this series. Customers switching from UK Fuels and Allstar specifically cite the transparency contrast.
Read full analysis →
fuelGenie
Supermarket fuel card · fuelgenie.co.uk
6.8
/10
4.1★ Trustpilot
Pump price — no mark-up
Limited network
Most transparent pricing in the market. Network restricted to ~2,200 supermarket and Shell sites — not suitable for motorway/HGV operators.
Read full analysis →
Allstar
Fuel card provider · allstarcard.co.uk
6.7
/10
7,700+ stations
Risk surcharge 30p+/L
Subscription trap
UK's largest network with genuine commercial savings for established fleets. Risk-based pricing surcharge and subscription fees create serious problems for affected customers.
Read full analysis →
Tesco Fuel Stations
Supermarket network · accessed via third parties
6.9
/10
700+ sites
Clubcard points
No own-brand card
Largest supermarket fuel network in the UK. No Tesco-branded card exists — experience depends entirely on the issuing provider chosen.
Read full analysis →
Morrisons Fuel Stations
Supermarket network · accessed via third parties
6.7
/10
330+ sites
Morrisons More points
No own-brand card
Competitive pump pricing and Morrisons More loyalty points. No own-brand card — access via fuelGenie, UK Fuels, Keyfuels, or Texaco Fastfuel.
Read full analysis →
Right Fuel Card
Fuel card broker · rightfuelcard.co.uk
6.5
/10
~5,000 Trustpilot reviews
Cancellation obstructed
Dormancy fees
Excellent onboarding and fast card delivery. Serious issues with cancellation obstruction and undisclosed fees on unused accounts.
Read full analysis →
Sainsbury's Fuel Stations
Supermarket network · accessed via third parties
6.6
/10
300+ sites
Nectar points
No own-brand card
Competitive supermarket pricing with Nectar point earning. Smaller network than Tesco but loyalty benefit adds real value for eligible businesses.
Read full analysis →
UK Fuels
Fuel card provider · ukfuels.co.uk
6.2
/10
97% UK coverage
Prices above pump
Hidden charges
Wide coverage and strong account manager reputation, but forum evidence consistently flags pricing above pump and hidden admin fees. Trustpilot score inflated by review solicitation.
Read full analysis →
Fuel Card Services
Fuel card broker · fuelcardservices.com
5.8
/10
4★ Trustpilot
3-month fee trigger
Upsell calls
Good account manager relationships undercut by automatic add-on service charges after 3 months, savings below what was promised, and persistent upselling.
Read full analysis →
Full League Table
| # | Provider | Score | Score bar | Key signal |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Fuelmate Broker |
8.7 | 4.9★ · Shell Reseller of Year 2025 · No negative reviews | |
| 2 | Tesco Fuel Stations Supermarket network |
6.9 | 700+ sites · Largest supermarket network · No own card | |
| 3 | fuelGenie Supermarket card |
6.8 | 4.1★ · Pump price, no mark-up · Network limited to ~2,200 sites | |
| 4 | Allstar Provider |
6.7 | 4.1★ · 7,700+ stations · Risk surcharge 30p+/L | |
| 4 | Morrisons Fuel Stations Supermarket network |
6.7 | 330+ sites · Competitive pricing · No own card | |
| 6 | Sainsbury's Fuel Stations Supermarket network |
6.6 | 300+ sites · Nectar points · No own card | |
| 7 | Right Fuel Card Broker |
6.5 | ~5,000 Trustpilot reviews · Cancellation complaints | |
| 8 | UK Fuels Provider |
6.2 | 97% UK coverage · Hidden charges · Prices above pump reported | |
| 9 | Fuel Card Services Broker |
5.8 | 4★ Trustpilot · 3-month add-on fee trigger | |
| 10 | The Fuelcard Company Broker |
5.2 | ~530 Trustpilot reviews · Opt-out fee model · Price spikes | |
| 11 | Radius Fuel Solutions Provider |
3.1 | 2.4★ Trustpilot · £80 late fee · Prices 12–15p above pump |